Bitcoin Faces Increased Selling Pressure During US Trading Hours
Bitcoin's performance during US trading hours has shown a notable decline, particularly as prices on Coinbase are trading at a $64 discount compared to Binance, the largest global cryptocurrency exchange. Since September 21, Bitcoin has experienced a compounded loss of 3.24% during US stock market hours, while prices outside of these hours have increased by 6.07%, according to an analysis by CryptoSlate.
The analysis indicates that the Coinbase Premium Gap, which measures the price difference between Coinbase and Binance, has fallen to -$64. This decline points to weaker demand or increased selling pressure on the US-focused exchange. The trend supports the view from Glassnode that the American trading session is exerting downward pressure on Bitcoin prices. However, it is important to note that the losses were heavily concentrated in just two trading sessions, complicating the narrative around persistent institutional selling.
For Your Trading Desk
Sponsor Spike Success.
From September 21 to October 7, Bitcoin fell during eight out of thirteen Wall Street cash sessions. The most significant declines occurred on September 30 and October 2, with prices dropping by 1.86% and 2.65%, respectively, during the New York trading hours from 9:30 a.m. to 4 p.m. When excluding these two dates, the remaining eleven sessions actually produced a compounded gain of 1.28%. This suggests that the overall narrative of a steady decline may be misleading, as much of the loss can be attributed to these sharp declines rather than a uniform pattern of selling.
The timing of the trading session also plays a crucial role in the observed performance. Starting the US session at 9 a.m. instead of 9:30 a.m. results in a compounded loss of 4.94% through 4 p.m., while starting at 10 a.m. leads to a 5.41% decline. Even when excluding the two significant drop dates, losses of 0.16% and 1.68% are still present, indicating that the specific opening time can significantly influence Bitcoin's performance during US trading hours.
Market Trends Show Diverging Bitcoin Activity During US Hours
Coinbase's price data reflects a similar trend, with Bitcoin declining approximately 4.85% between 9 a.m. and 4 p.m. and 5.36% from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. This consistency across both exchanges strengthens the timing signal, although it does not clarify the identities of the market participants involved. The data does not specify whether the sellers are US institutions, retail traders, or global investors active during American business hours.
Glassnode recently noted that Bitcoin's net gains since September 21 have primarily occurred outside of US trading hours, reversing a previous trend where American trading sessions contributed more significantly to price increases. Fund flows into US spot Bitcoin ETFs provide further insight into the market dynamics. On September 30, these ETFs recorded net outflows of $148.7 million, coinciding with the first major decline during US trading hours. However, just two days later, the funds attracted $189.9 million in inflows, even as Bitcoin fell 2.65% during Wall Street hours. This divergence suggests that ETF investors alone cannot account for the observed weakness during US trading sessions.
ETF Outflows Signal Shifting Investor Sentiment in Bitcoin Market
The outflows from Bitcoin ETFs became more pronounced on October 7, with net withdrawals reaching $484.9 million. This indicates that while demand from these funds has weakened at times, the daily totals do not clarify when Bitcoin was sold or which investors were responsible for driving prices lower. The mechanics of ETF redemptions add another layer of complexity, as withdrawals can involve transferring Bitcoin rather than an immediate cash sale.
The persistent discount on Coinbase serves as an important indicator of market sentiment but does not definitively prove institutional selling. A sustained negative premium suggests weaker pricing on an exchange closely associated with US investors, yet it cannot identify the specific traders behind individual transactions. The upcoming trading sessions will be critical in determining whether this pattern of selling during US hours continues, and whether the Coinbase discount remains deeply negative alongside increasing ETF outflows. If Bitcoin continues to lose ground during these hours, it could strengthen the case for a decline in US demand. Conversely, a recovery in US-session returns without a corresponding rebound in ETF flows may indicate other factors at play, such as market makers or derivatives positioning influencing the market during American trading hours.




