Impact of Stock Market Concentration on Fund Performance and Regulation
Recent research highlights the growing concentration of the U.S. stock market, where the share of the ten largest stocks in total market capitalization surged from 13% in 2015 to 31% in 2024. This trend has significant implications for mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs), particularly under the 50/5/10 rule, which restricts the proportion of assets that can be invested in any single stock. As these funds approach this regulatory limit, they are compelled to reduce their holdings in large-cap stocks, which can adversely affect their performance and the prices of those stocks.
The 50/5/10 rule requires that at least 50% of a fund's assets be in securities where no single issuer exceeds 5% of the fund's assets or 10% of the issuer's voting securities. Historically, this rule was not a significant constraint for diversified equity funds, but as the largest companies have grown, it has become increasingly binding. For instance, by the end of 2024, approximately 6% of total domestic equity fund assets were constrained by this rule, with large-cap growth funds particularly affected.
For Your Trading Desk
Sponsor Spike Success.
The research analyzed quarterly holdings of 4,745 U.S. domestic equity funds from 2019 to 2024, revealing that constrained funds often underperform. The average risk-adjusted returns for large-cap growth funds were significantly lower when constrained, particularly in the tightest regulatory periods of 2023-2024. This underperformance may stem from the necessity to sell or underweight stocks that subsequently perform well, leading to potential underpricing of these stocks in the market.
The study also introduced a measure of constrained ownership, indicating that stocks with high levels of constrained ownership may be undervalued. The total market capitalization of stocks affected by this constraint grew from $11 trillion in 2019 to $41 trillion in 2024, representing over 60% of the aggregate U.S. market capitalization. Notably, stocks like Nvidia and Microsoft were identified as having significant constrained ownership values.
The findings suggest that both active and passive funds are influenced by these regulatory constraints, with active funds experiencing a more pronounced impact on stock returns. While the 50/5/10 rule serves an important protective role for investors, the research calls for a reassessment of such diversification rules in light of the current market landscape, which is increasingly dominated by a small number of mega-cap stocks. The key question is how these rules should adapt to ensure they do not hinder the ability of funds to express optimistic views in a concentrated market.




