S&P 500 Dividend Yields Drop Below 10-Year Treasury Income
The income potential of owning stocks has diminished significantly as the S&P 500's dividend yield has decreased to about 1.05%. In contrast, the yield on the 10-year Treasury note is currently near 4.74%. This disparity has not been seen since before the global financial crisis, with only 3.85% of S&P 500 constituents now providing yields that exceed those of the 10-year Treasury, a stark decline from over 63% a decade ago.
Data from Ned Davis Research, shared by analyst Liz Ann Sonders, highlights this trend, noting that the current ratio of S&P 500 stocks out-yielding the 10-year Treasury is the lowest since May 2007. To understand the gravity of this shift, one can look back to July 2016, when 63.4% of S&P 500 stocks offered yields higher than the 10-year Treasury. Since then, Treasury yields have normalized following the pandemic-era rate hikes, while the average dividend yield of the S&P 500 has remained below 2% since 2020, often hovering around or below 1.1%.
For Your Trading Desk
Sponsor Spike Success.
The decline in equity dividend yields is not solely due to companies reducing their payouts. It results from a combination of factors. First, the S&P 500's valuations have risen to levels where even consistent dividend payments yield minimal returns. For instance, if a stock's price doubles while its dividend remains unchanged, the yield effectively halves.
Second, there has been a notable preference among corporations for share buybacks over increasing dividends, altering the landscape of capital returns. Third, the index's composition has shifted, with mega-cap technology companies increasingly dominating. Many of these firms either do not pay dividends or provide minimal amounts relative to their market capitalizations.
For investors focused on income generation, fixed-income securities, particularly Treasuries, now present a more attractive option. Retirees constructing portfolios aimed at cash flow may find little incentive to accept the risks associated with equities for yields that are roughly one-fifth of what government bonds currently offer.
The last time such a small percentage of S&P 500 stocks out-yielded the 10-year Treasury was in mid-2007. While this does not guarantee a repeat of past outcomes, it does suggest that significant disparities between equity and bond income often align with late-cycle market dynamics.




