Commodities Outperform Tech This Decade Despite Wall Street Hesitation
Commodities have proven to be the standout asset class of this decade, significantly outperforming technology investments. Since October 2020, broad commodity indices such as the S&P GSCI have surged by 200 percent, with gold increasing by 140 percent. This year alone, commodities have risen by 37 percent, driven largely by an 81 percent increase in petroleum prices. Despite these impressive returns, Wall Street's investment in energy and basic materials remains minimal, accounting for less than six percent of the S&P 500, a stark contrast to their historical weight.
Institutional investors initially reduced their exposure to real assets, citing sustainability concerns, while simultaneously investing heavily in green energy that relies on substantial amounts of raw materials like copper. Six years later, the anticipated capital reallocation has not materialized, creating what some analysts refer to as the physical capital paradox. Investors have favored technology, particularly in artificial intelligence, which has led to one of the largest commodity shorts in history. The so-called Magnificent Seven tech companies are projected to spend nearly $800 billion this year, with a significant portion allocated for raw materials and energy, including copper and critical minerals.
For Your Trading Desk
Sponsor Spike Success.
The energy consumption associated with AI infrastructure is staggering, with the top five buyers of AI compute requiring nearly four million barrels of oil equivalent daily, surpassing the energy needs of many industrialized nations. This demand is not expected to peak but rather to compound, as the transition to mechanization continues. The historical sequence of mechanization followed by digitalization is being challenged; AI is set to redefine the mechanization landscape, where every robot requires essential materials such as copper and rare earth elements.
In contrast to the tech giants, the Munificent Seven—major oil and gas companies like ExxonMobil, Chevron, and Shell—are positioned to benefit from this demand. These companies are returning 14 to 15 cents of free cash flow per dollar of market value, compared to just two cents for their tech counterparts. Despite record margins in diesel and gasoline due to ongoing geopolitical tensions, these energy firms are trading at lower valuations than before significant conflicts like the US-Iran war.
The reluctance of investors to shift their allocations is rooted in the scars left by the capital destruction experienced in the 2010s when investments in energy and metals led to significant losses. Currently, passive investment strategies tend to favor larger, trending assets, disregarding price signals. This trend suggests that even continued strong performance in commodities may not prompt a change in investment behavior.
Historically, shifts in investment allocations have occurred in response to crises rather than performance metrics. The 1970s energy crisis and the 2000s demand surge from China exemplify how visible scarcity drives investment. Today, the market is on the brink of a similar crisis, as record demand growth is not being met with adequate supply-side investment. The depletion of spare capacity and strategic reserves further exacerbates the situation, indicating that the next disruption is imminent.
Ultimately, the paradox of underinvestment in physical assets may culminate in a crisis that forces investors to confront the reality of their neglect. While the potential for high returns in commodities is evident, the market may only respond when it is compelled to do so, leading to a surge of capital at a higher cost when the crisis unfolds. The opportunity has been visible all along, yet it remains largely unclaimed by investors.




